India’s Hunger Index rating is poor – Flying Journals


India claims GHI report ignores government’s food security measures

New Delhi:

India today called the latest Global Hunger Index (GHI) report a “mismeasurement of hunger” and claimed it had “serious methodological problems” after slipping to 107th out of 121 countries in 2022 .

“Three of the four indicators used to calculate the index relate to children’s health and are not representative of the entire population,” said a press note issued by the Alliance’s Ministry of Women and Child Development.

It further states: “The fourth and most important indicator estimate for the proportion of undernourished (PoU) is based on a poll conducted with a very small sample size of 3,000. Not only is the report out of touch with the reality on the ground, it chooses to deliberately ignore the government Efforts to ensure people’s food security, especially during the Covid-19 pandemic.”

India ranks 101st in the 2021 ranking. Its current 107th place is behind neighboring Pakistan, Bangladesh and Nepal. The GHI website, which tracks hunger and malnutrition, said Saturday that 17 countries, including China, Turkey and Kuwait, topped the list with GHI scores below 5.

“From a one-dimensional perspective, the report lowers India’s ranking based on an estimate of the proportion of undernourished (PoU) population in India at 16.3%,” the ministry’s statement further said.

“This matter has been dealt with by the FAO,” the statement said. [Food and Agricultural Organisation] Such estimates based on FIES are not used [Food Insecurity Experience Scale] Survey module data for July 2022, as the same statistical output will not be based on merit. It is unfortunate that the Global Hunger Index report was published without these factual considerations, despite the imminent assurances of further engagement on this issue. “

The statement from the Ministry of Women and Child Development raised serious questions about some of the questions the investigators asked Indian respondents. It said: “Some of the questions asked of respondents were: ‘In the past 12 months, have you ever been concerned about not having enough food to eat due to lack of funds or other resources? You have eaten less than you thought ?'”

“It is clear that such questions are not fact-finding based on information about providing nutritional support and ensuring food security,” the ministry said.

The ministry further said that calculating hunger based primarily on indicators related to child health indicators is “neither scientific nor reasonable”.



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *